Daily Hypernovelty Lead · Law & evidence · October 20, 2026
The Return Projection Needs a Reader
An SEC order dated October 15 and published October 20 approves a limited opening for broker-dealers to share investment performance projections and targeted returns. Under the approved change to FINRA Rule 2210, the firm has to consider who will receive the communication and whether the explanation fits that audience, while keeping records about the figure's source. The order does not specify an implementation date. Its audience conditions address a problem that follows a forecast when it moves from a specialist's desk into general circulation.

FINRA's rule generally prohibits member broker-dealers from predicting or projecting performance in communications with the public, subject to existing exceptions. The approved change creates a fourth exception covering a security, a securities portfolio, or an asset allocation or other investment strategy. It concerns communications by FINRA members, rather than financial speech generally, and does not open every category of hypothetical performance. FINRA declined requests to add categories such as backtested and model performance to this exception.
Within that narrower opening, the distinction between an estimate and an ambition can be easy to miss. FINRA describes a projection as an estimate of future performance, often based on historical data and assumptions. A targeted return is an aspirational goal. FINRA retained the same conditions for both because investors may not appreciate the difference.
The reader becomes part of the review
For a firm deciding whom to send either figure to, the approved framework requires written policies and procedures reasonably designed to ensure that a communication is relevant to the intended audience's likely financial situation and investment objectives. FINRA says distribution should reach investors whom the member reasonably believes have access to resources to analyze the information independently and the financial expertise to understand its risks and limitations. That leaves room for qualifying retail investors, while generally excluding projections aimed at a mass audience or general retail circulation.
Interest in high returns, FINRA says, is insufficient by itself to establish relevance.
Once a firm has identified an appropriate audience, it still has to explain the figure. Reviewing the document without considering its recipients leaves part of that job unfinished: if a presentation moves to a different audience, the earlier judgment about relevance and explanation may need revisiting. A warning paragraph attached to the file cannot settle that audience question on its own.
The disclosures must give the intended audience enough information to understand the calculation's criteria and assumptions, together with the risks and limitations of using the result. Those obligations survived amendments that removed express requirements to state whether figures are net of anticipated fees and expenses and to explain why actual performance might differ. FINRA says those subjects may still need disclosure under the remaining requirements and existing standards against misleading omissions. Removing the specified wording did not make material context optional.
The proposal's treatment of the figure's evidentiary basis changed too: FINRA removed its separate express reasonable-basis requirement and amended the recordkeeping provision to call for information about the source of a projection or target. Existing fair-and-balanced, nonmisleading content standards remain. The SEC concluded that those standards, combined with recordkeeping, effectively require firms to substantiate the basis before communicating a projection.
For a firm using material supplied by someone else, that leaves a question about how far its own review must go. FINRA does not generally expect a member to independently verify every underlying criterion and assumption. It does expect the firm to evaluate the source, assess whether available information supports the presentation, and satisfy itself that the communication meets the content standards. The diligence required depends on the circumstances.
Verification bottleneck
The scarce check is whether this version of a projection is adequately supported and explained for the people selected to receive it.
- Distribution teams need an audience decision that remains connected to the actual communication, rather than a broad label such as “interested investors.”
- Reviewers need to connect the figure to its source and the assumptions and limitations disclosed alongside it, including material supplied by another firm.
- Watch for FINRA's implementation announcements and any further guidance. The October 15 approval and October 20 publication dates should not be substituted for an implementation date.
Opportunities
A useful tool could link each approved document version to its source material and intended audience, then flag a distribution change for review. That would help a reviewer see when a presentation prepared for one group is being reused for another, rather than treating the document's earlier approval as sufficient for every recipient.
An accompanying review service could check whether the explanation makes sense for the intended reader and identify missing material for a qualified compliance reviewer. These are workflow ideas, rather than products mandated by the order or evidence of proven demand. Their value would depend on whether they improve actual review without creating another pile of forms.
The order permits a wider range of investment communications under conditions. It supplies no validation of a particular forecast. Readers still need to understand how the figure was produced and what could make the outcome differ before treating it as a basis for a decision.
Sources
General orientation, not investment, legal, or compliance advice.