HYPERNOVELTYINSTITUTE

Technical intelligence
for accelerating change.

Search the record

Home/Analysis

Daily Hypernovelty Lead · November 12, 2026

After the Dollar, What Makes One Worth One?

Europe is rebuilding parts of its payment system while continuing to use the money already in people's bank accounts. Wero, the bank-backed European payment initiative, uses existing instant account-to-account infrastructure to move those balances. Its ambition is a European alternative to established payment providers. A customer can keep paying in euros while the companies handling the payment, and the dependencies behind it, change.

A brass balance compares stacked gold bars with a clear glass cube on an archive desk, with electrical infrastructure beyond the window.

The European Central Bank is working on different parts of the system. In a November 10 statement, it described Pontes, launched in September, as connecting distributed-ledger platforms with the Eurosystem's TARGET services so tokenised transactions can settle in central bank money. Its retail digital-euro pilot is planned for the second half of 2027, involving Eurosystem staff, participating payment providers and selected merchants, using a beta version without legal-tender status. A possible first issuance still depends on legislation.

Wero changes how customers pay from bank accounts. Pontes connects institutional markets to central-bank settlement. A retail digital euro would introduce another way for the public to hold and use central bank money. A privately issued euro stablecoin would add a different issuer's promise again. Calling all of them digital money conceals more than it explains.

That distinction opens a much larger question. We can change the infrastructure, the institutions collecting fees and the conditions for access while leaving the currency's name alone. If a different monetary unit eventually emerges, what would make it credible enough to use alongside the dollar, or in its place?

One dollar, several promises

The phrase "worth one" carries several meanings that are easy to slide between.

A dollar in a bank account can exchange at face value for another form of the same currency. That is different from keeping its purchasing power over time, holding its exchange rate against another currency, or being redeemable for a fixed quantity of something physical.

The Bank for International Settlements calls the first relationship the singleness of money: different forms of money settle at par against the same unit of account. Commercial banks issue deposits; central-bank reserves provide the common settlement asset behind transactions between banks. Regulation and deposit protection also support confidence in that arrangement.

Maintaining that relationship doesn't keep the grocery bill fixed. A system can preserve one-for-one conversion between forms of a currency while the currency buys less food or fuel. A future monetary design has to say which problem it intends to solve before we can judge whether its proposed backing helps.

The Federal Reserve states plainly that its notes are not redeemable in gold, silver or another commodity. Using dollars to price oil doesn't give a dollar holder a contractual right to collect a fixed amount of oil. The economic importance of energy and a legal promise of energy redemption are separate things.

The same distinction travels onto a blockchain. Circle's USDC terms for holders outside the European Economic Area promise redemption at one dollar per USDC, subject to their conditions. Direct redemption requires an eligible Circle Mint account. Other holders may depend on an exchange or another intermediary to convert their tokens.

A balance on a screen can look simple while the path from that balance to spendable money remains conditional. And a dollar stablecoin keeps its reference to the dollar. If it makes dollar-denominated payments easier in more places, it could extend the currency's reach even while changing the institutions through which people access it.

The assets can move before the unit changes

Payment networks are only part of this story. Securities and collateral are changing form too.

DTCC launched its Tokenization Service on October 28, allowing eligible users to obtain tokenised representations of eligible securities entitlements held at its DTC subsidiary. DTCC says these representations retain the ownership rights, investor protections and economic entitlements of their traditional counterparts.

That preservation of rights is consequential. A token representing an existing securities entitlement differs from a product that merely follows a stock's price. The word token tells you little about which one you're holding.

An existing dollar-denominated bond can change how it is recorded and transferred without changing what its issuer owes. Tokenisation alone doesn't cancel the debt or replace the dollar. It can nevertheless alter who can reach the asset, where it can move and how readily it can be used in another transaction.

The BIS has proposed bringing tokenised central-bank reserves, commercial-bank money and financial assets together on a programmable platform. Its preferred design preserves central banks at the centre. That is an institutional position about how the system should develop, and a useful reminder that technical innovation can strengthen an existing monetary architecture.

The immediate possibilities include less repetitive processing and easier movement of collateral. The harder questions concern access and dependence: which institutions can connect, which assets qualify, whose records prevail in a dispute, and what happens if a participant loses access?

For someone holding a claim, continuity of enforceable rights belongs in the comparison alongside speed.

A common network doesn't settle the currency question

Different countries can connect their payment systems while retaining different currencies. Conversion could happen within a shared service, or through gateways between networks. People might experience something close to one payment interface without sharing a monetary unit.

That is one possible future. Another is a common settlement instrument used between institutions while households continue earning and spending national currencies. A more ambitious arrangement would place a shared unit directly into commercial and ordinary life.

These possibilities demand different levels of agreement. Connecting systems requires rules for access, finality and disputes. Sharing a monetary unit adds questions about issuance, emergency credit and the distribution of losses. Moving from one to the other would be a political and economic choice, not an automatic consequence of compatible software.

Countries seeking fewer dollar dependencies may also want different things. Avoiding a particular sanctions exposure is different from reducing payment costs or obtaining more reliable trade finance. Agreement about an existing system's disadvantages doesn't establish agreement about who should carry the next system's risks.

A country may welcome an alternative network and still refuse to guarantee another participant's debts. That disagreement can survive every technical improvement.

What would the new unit be a claim on?

Gold, energy and baskets of assets enter this discussion because they appear to give money a reference outside the discretion of any one government. Each deserves examination beyond its appeal as a slogan.

Gold can constrain a promise to issue redeemable claims, provided the issuer actually maintains and honours that constraint. It cannot decide who receives emergency credit or supply additional metal on demand during a panic. Those responsibilities return to the institutions operating the system, including whatever credit arrangements they build around the underlying asset.

An instrument linked to productive assets involves a different promise. A claim on a power station's revenues can carry business risk and offer investment returns. It doesn't automatically provide a stable unit for setting wages or comparing the price of groceries. Ownership of useful production and suitability as money are different tests.

The IMF's Special Drawing Right provides an existing example of a shared reference. Its value is based on a basket of five currencies. It is an international reserve asset and an institutional unit of account; individuals cannot hold SDRs, and it isn't a retail currency.

The SDR shows that countries can govern a common reference without becoming one state. It leaves a considerable distance between that arrangement and a currency people would use for rent or payroll.

A future basket might reference currencies, commodities or productive capacity. But the design would have to distinguish an index from a redeemable claim. Tracking the market price of a basket doesn't necessarily entitle the holder to receive its components. Holding actual backing introduces custody, valuation and delivery obligations.

Then someone must select the components and their weights. Changing those weights can benefit some participants and disadvantage others. A basket can distribute exposure across several assets while concentrating authority in whoever gets to revise it.

Cheap energy could be awkward money

Energy is an understandable candidate because producing and moving things requires it. An energy reference seems to connect money to a physical requirement of economic life. The details become difficult almost immediately.

A promise to deliver electricity needs a place and a time. Solar output when supply is plentiful isn't interchangeable with guaranteed power during an evening shortage. Transmission capacity and storage affect whether the promised electricity can reach the person entitled to it.

IRENA's work on battery storage describes precisely this problem: storage moves electricity from periods of surplus toward periods when it is needed. It also documents how technology and manufacturing have reduced storage costs. The physical constraints are real, and they can change.

An energy-redeemable unit would therefore need delivery and shortage rules. An energy-price-indexed unit could settle financially without delivering any electricity. A token financing a generator would involve another set of rights. Describing each as energy-backed doesn't make their promises equivalent.

Consider what happens if energy becomes substantially cheaper relative to other things.

Suppose a unit remains redeemable for a specified amount of electricity, and technology makes that electricity easier to produce and deliver. The unit could become easier for its issuer to honour while buying fewer other goods. It would still command the same electricity, but energy's exchange value against housing, materials or labour could fall.

That would be a success for energy production and a problem for anyone who expected the instrument to preserve purchasing power more broadly. The same technical achievement could improve the physical promise and weaken the financial expectation attached to it.

The opposite pressure is possible too. New demand could absorb cheaper supply, while grid access or reliable delivery remains expensive. Advances in generation don't guarantee that every user receives abundant power at a lower price.

This is where Hypernovelty complicates the search for a permanent monetary anchor. Technology may change the scarcity of the thing we choose to measure value against. It could also move the constraint elsewhere, toward transmission, storage, materials, computing capacity or access to infrastructure.

A unit of compute would need to specify the task and performance being promised. Hardware improvements can change the cost of providing it. A monetary reference would have to cope with that progress rather than treat computing capacity as an economically unchanging commodity.

A changing basket might adapt to these shifts. But revising the basket brings us back to authority. Who decides that energy has become abundant enough to receive a lower weight, or that another resource now deserves a larger one? How would someone who saved under the old definition challenge that decision?

Global rules, without assuming a global government

A formal global government is one possible setting for a shared currency. It is a much larger political proposition than connecting payment networks, and the networks being built don't establish that it will happen.

Treaties, coordinated central banks or a jointly governed institution could support narrower arrangements. Private networks could also become widely used across borders while remaining subject to several jurisdictions. A common unit could coexist with national currencies instead of replacing them.

Any arrangement that becomes important enough would encounter pressure for decisions that reach beyond one country. A widely used settlement instrument needs a credible answer when obligations cannot be met. Someone must decide whether to supply liquidity, demand more collateral, delay payment or allocate losses.

The BIS treats the ability to provide enough liquidity for large payments to settle without gridlock as one of the monetary system's central requirements. A hard limit on issuance can appeal to savers concerned about dilution while making emergency funding harder. Allowing discretion can ease a crisis while creating arguments about who received help and who paid for it.

Neither a commodity nor a blockchain removes that conflict. They can change its conditions, constrain some decisions and make others more visible. The rules still have to address it.

Monetary governance could consequently become more international without producing a single world government. It could also remain fragmented, with cooperation limited to particular networks or transactions. The useful question is how much authority each arrangement requires participants to share, and whether they will still accept its decisions when those decisions become costly.

What would change the picture?

A new wallet offers weak evidence of a new monetary order. More consequential developments would include contracts priced in a different unit, substantial settlement in that unit outside its issuer's own circle, and enforceable redemption arrangements that continue working under stress.

For an energy-linked instrument, actual delivery would tell us more than the phrase energy-backed. For a basket, published valuation and revision rules would matter alongside the asset list. For a shared system, its response to the first serious disagreement over liquidity or losses would reveal something a successful technology demonstration cannot.

Today's CBDCs and stablecoins may prove durable, intermediate or useful only for particular functions. They could help existing currencies travel further. They could coexist with a later shared reference. Different parts of the system may arrive at different answers.

For ordinary holders, the questions are already practical: what does this balance entitle me to receive, who owes it to me, how can I get it out, and who can change those terms? A familiar currency name or a polished wallet doesn't answer them.

Even if the dollar remains central, changes in the claims and institutions around it can alter people's experience of money. If another unit gains acceptance, its credibility will depend on the promise people are willing to accept, and on what happens when honouring that promise becomes difficult.

Back to the archive